-
Review of Meta-analysis Research on Exercise in South Korea
-
Youngshin Song, Moonhee Gang, Sun-Ae Kim, In-Soo Shin
-
J Korean Acad Nurs 2014;44(5):459-470. Published online October 31, 2014
-
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4040/jkan.2014.44.5.459
-
-
 Abstract
 PDF
-
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the quality of meta-analysis regarding exercise using Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR) as well as to compare effect size according to outcomes.
Methods
Electronic databases including the Korean Studies Information Service System (KISS), the National Assembly Library and the DBpia, HAKJISAand RISS4U for the dates 1990 to January 2014 were searched for 'meta-analysis' and 'exercise' in the fields of medical, nursing, physical therapy and physical exercise in Korea. AMSTAR was scored for quality assessment of the 33 articles included in the study. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, t-test, ANOVA and χ2-test.
Results
The mean score for AMSTAR evaluations was 4.18 (SD=1.78) and about 67% were classified at the low-quality level and 30% at the moderate-quality level. The scores of quality were statistically different by field of research, number of participants, number of databases, financial support and approval by IRB. The effect size that presented in individual studies were different by type of exercise in the applied intervention.
Conclusion
This critical appraisal of meta-analysis published in various field that focused on exercise indicates that a guideline such as the PRISMA checklist should be strongly recommended for optimum reporting of meta-analysis across research fields.
-
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by  - Effectiveness of sensory integration therapy in children, focusing on Korean children: A systematic review and meta-analysis
Seri Oh, Jong-Sik Jang, A-Ra Jeon, Geonwoo Kim, Mihwa Kwon, Bahoe Cho, Narae Lee
World Journal of Clinical Cases.2024; 12(7): 1260. CrossRef - A Methodological Quality Evaluation of Meta-Analyses on Nursing Home Research: Overview and Suggestions for Future Directions
In-Soo Shin, Juh-Hyun Shin, Dong-Eun Jang, Jiyeon Lee
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2022; 19(1): 505. CrossRef - Methodological Quality Assessment of Meta-Analyses in the Field of Korean Occupational Therapy Using the Korean Journal of Occupational Therapy
Yoo-Im Choi, Se-Yun Kim
Journal of Korean Society of Occupational Therapy.2020; 28(3): 71. CrossRef - Methodological Qualitative Evaluation of Meta-analysis Studies in Sport Management
Sanghyun Park, Minseok Kwag
The Korean Journal of Physical Education.2018; 57(1): 247. CrossRef - Evaluation of methodological quality of meta-analysis studies in early childhood education
PARK SEO-HYUN
Korean Journal of Early Childhood Education.2018; 38(5): 131. CrossRef - The Feature of the Program components in the Meta Analysis Research: Evidence Based Program Development Perspective
In Hae Seo, Kong Gye-Soon
Korean Journal of Social Welfare Studies.2018; 49(3): 247. CrossRef - Trends in Evidence-based Nursing Research in South Korea
Seang Ryu, Sun Weon Yun, Yun Sook Kim
Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing Administration.2017; 23(4): 385. CrossRef - A Quality Assessment of Systematic Review of Oriental Medicine in South Korea
Yun-Young Kim, Hye Sun Hyun
Journal of Digital Convergence.2015; 13(10): 549. CrossRef - Methodological Quality of Meta-Analyses on the Elderly in Korea
송영신, 김선애, 강문희
Korean Journal of Local Government & Administration Studies.2014; 28(4): 349. CrossRef
-
182
View
-
0
Download
-
9
Crossref
|
KSNS
E-SUBMISSION
